South Korea's first serial killer—did he truly murder all 17 people?
On the November 19 broadcast of SBS's "Tails of Tales," the program shed light on Kim Dae-du, South Korea's first serial killer, under the subtitle "Kim Dae-du: South Korea's First Serial Killer."
In October 1975, South Korea's first serial killer, who murdered as many as 17 people over 55 days, was apprehended.
The man who brutally slaughtered victims ranging from people in their 70s to a three-month-old infant was none other than Kim Dae-du. Claiming he committed the crimes in an attempt to live well, he stated his motive: "I wanted to make money and live large, even if it meant doing bad things." However, the money he stole through his crimes amounted to a mere 25,000 won, worth roughly 250,000 won in today's value.
Furthermore, having targeted even an infant, he sparked outrage by saying, "I killed the young child because it was crying. I killed because killing a few more didn't make a difference anyway."
Unabashed, Kim Dae-du even chuckled during the on-site crime reenactment, appearing as a monstrous killer devoid of any guilt.
Yet ahead of his trial, he suddenly fell silent. Offering neither excuses nor pleas of unfairness, Kim Dae-du admitted to all charges and showed a different attitude than before. On December 28, 1976, he perished on the gallows.
However, in 2003, nearly 30 years after his death, film director Kim Bong-han, harboring doubts about the case, visited Deaconess Kim Hye-won, with whom Kim Dae-du had exchanged letters during his lifetime.
To Deaconess Kim Hye-won, who was known as the godmother of death row inmates, Kim Dae-du sent letters seemingly expressing belated regret over his crimes, writing, "I am sorry to the victims, and I want to convey those words."
Furthermore, Kim Dae-du expressed a desire to donate his organs following his execution, raising questions about whether he was truly the monstrous murderer he was made out to be.
Director Kim Bong-han became even more suspicious upon seeing letters written in handwritings so disparate that they seemed impossible to have been penned by a single individual. In fact, to the naked eye, the handwriting styles in the letters appeared completely different. In response, the production team requested a handwriting analysis, and the results determined they were written by the same person. The difference in handwriting was due to the writing instruments used.
Nevertheless, many questions remained regarding the Kim Dae-du case. Kim Dae-du had claimed money was his motive, yet his targets were exclusively vulnerable individuals.
Moreover, for someone who had roamed across the entire country committing murders at the time, Kim Dae-du's mobility was remarkably poor. In addition, after his final sentencing, Kim Dae-du appeared remorseful to the point where people wondered if he was the same person.
Director Kim Bong-han expressed his skepticism, remarking, "Did Kim Dae-du really kill all 17 people? My biggest curiosity was: Why? I wanted to ask, 'Did you really kill them all?'"
The production team conducted profiling on Kim Dae-du alongside a profiler. They revealed that his true motive was not money, but anger toward society.
It was also revealed that because his crimes were extremely impulsive and spontaneous, his targets were chosen on impulse as well. In particular, because he was an extremely fearful person, he targeted only vulnerable individuals in isolated areas.
And due to that fearful, cowardly, and timid personality, he seemed to abandon everything and appear remorseful about his crimes after receiving the death penalty.
A profiler stated, "From a modern perspective, Kim Dae-du could not be indicted as a serial killer," adding, "An indictment would be impossible solely based on his past criminal record and his confession. Therefore, it raises doubts as to whether all of these were the work of the same perpetrator." Indeed, there was no direct evidence even in Kim Dae-du's court ruling.
Following Kim Dae-du's confession on October 8, 1975, the news of the arrest of South Korea's first serial killer was reported on October 9, and Kim Dae-du's crime reenactment took place on October 10.
It appeared as if the process had been rushed simply to secure the distinction of "South Korea's first serial killer." Consequently, the investigation was inevitably shoddy.
An expert noted, "There were many pieces of direct evidence that could easily be uncovered today. Even so, it is regrettable that they did not proceed a bit more slowly and conduct a more meticulous investigation back then."
The expert drew attention by adding, "If there is even a single victim he did not kill, how unfair would that be for those victims and their families? That is why the exact truth must be uncovered. Even if a criminal is in the grave, the truth must be revealed. That is the reason criminal investigations and the police exist. No one should be left with an unresolved injustice."
Director Kim Bong-han, who questioned the Kim Dae-du case, explained that his motive for directing the film "Ordinary Person" based on the incident was to convey the message that "rather than looking at an incident merely on the surface, we need to look deeper and reflect on it once more."
This serves as a reminder that to uncover the truth, even with the passage of time, one must explore every possible doubt.
※
Copying, redistribution, and unauthorized use in AI training are strictly prohibited.